>Users:   login   |  register       > email     > people    


Commentary on Criminal Justice Reform in Massachusetts
By William Sturgeon
Published: 10/08/2018

Juvenile justice courthouse First and foremost, a “Well Done” to the Massachusetts Legislature and Governor Baker for their efforts to reform the Massachusetts Criminal Justice System! As a person who has spent most of his adult life working at various levels and positions in the criminal justice system, serious reform has been needed for years.

Again, “Well Done” Massachusetts!

The current reform of the Massachusetts criminal justice system is the beginning of a much longer and complicated process, in my opinion. The American criminal justice system is a patchwork of kneejerk fixes to immediate situations, most of the time without any current and relevant research to validate the fix.

As I read the WBUR News article (April 6, 2018) written by Steve Brown, I was pleased to read that the Legislature addressed some of the serious issues affecting the Juvenile Justice System. Yet there are so many more issues associated with juvenile justice, and most of the issues are complicated and challenging.

I would, however, criticize some of the “fixes” (to the juvenile justice system) that the Legislature passed. Specifically, what bothers me most is the continuing use of chronological age as a determining justice factor for juvenile justice. With all of the modern scientific testing and evaluation methods, one would think that these twenty-first century tools would be employed during the juvenile adjudication process. Some of the twenty-first century tools are: I.Q. testing, psychosocial testing, psychological testing, complete physical examination, and, if determined necessary, an MRI or Cat Scan. Also, testing for traumatic brain injury. Looking back on my work with adjudicated juveniles / youthful offenders and knowing what I know now about traumatic brain injury, I am convinced that some of the youthful offenders that I came into contact with were suffering from traumatic brain injury.

If the Commonwealth really wants to have a juvenile justice system that will really help kids, then it should use every tool available to it to have the best juvenile justice system in the United States.

These current changes to the Massachusetts Criminal Justice System, in my opinion, mainly addressed the “end users” of the criminal justice system:
  • Juvenile Justice
  • Bail Reform
  • More Use of Diversion Programs
  • Expungement
  • Solitary Confinement and Compassionate Release
  • Elimination of Mandatory Minimums for Certain Low-Level Drug Offenses
  • Fentanyl and Carfentanil Trafficking
The most urgent and demanding need, I believe, is preventing children from becoming involved with the criminal justice system initially! A great deal has been written and discussed about the “Pipeline from high school to jail”. In reality, the “pipeline” starts well before high school.

My experience has shown me that society and the juvenile justice system lack the will to incorporate 21st century methods for dealing with children living in borderline, even dangerous environments where violence and disrespect is a way of life. The foster system is overburdened and, in some cases, misused. Many children should be removed from their living environments because of lack of parenting skills/involvement/care/abuse/neglect, or because there are family member(s) who already are involved with the criminal justice system, problems in school, and familial addiction issues.

My involvement with “Youthful Offenders” has helped me to define the above areas. These are the environments that they came from. The youths, mostly in their teens, had been “adjudicated adults” and sentenced to an adult penitentiary because of the serious nature of their crimes. Many of them had served time in juvenile detention. After spending numerous hours talking with them while they were incarcerated, it clearly demonstrated to me that the crime that landed them in the penitentiary was the result of many missed opportunities to correct their behavior and to prevent their incarceration. While they committed very serious and violent crimes, most of them they were just teenage boys with all the physical, psychological and emotional challenges that go along with being a teenager. It is my assertion that in many of the cases that I am familiar with, the “system” let them down. If there had been some effective intervention early on, perhaps some ofthese youthful offenders might not have been in prison. However, I am not excusing they crimes that committed that resulted in their being incarcerated.

There have been so many medical, psychological and studies of the developing brain that should be used when dealing with children who show a propensity to criminal acts or who have become involved with the criminal justice system.

There are those who believe that the obstacles to real criminal justice reform are the following:
  • Worrying about political correctness throughout the process.
  • Making the assumption that involvement with the criminal justice system only involves minorities and the poor. The infusion of opiates and other drugs on society puts everyone at risk.
  • Addressing only the symptoms that define the real problems. Addressing the real problems takes courage and knowledge more than a campaign slogan or newspaper headline might suggest.
  • Not realizing that solving the problems, once defined, will be lengthy and costly.
  • Making excuses for the human behavior instead of helping those individuals to correct it.
  • Using the victim’s rationale for criminal activity.
My retorts to the above obstacles are:
  • Too many people are afraid to “drill down” to identify the problem and to recommend solutions because they will be accused of some political prejudice. So, our children continue to join gangs, live in abusive homes, live on the streets, do drugs, buy guns, commit suicide, and kill each other! There is ample ‘real world” and statistical evidence that can be used to identify the causes.
  • Assuming that only minority and poor children get involved with the criminal justice system is just wrong. The real difference is people, regardless of race, with the financial ability to hire top class lawyers to have an advantage in today’s criminal justice system. Yes, there are issues in minority communities and there are also issues in well to do communities; they are just disguised better.
  • Yes, it is easier to address symptoms of problems than to find the cause. I believe that we know many of the causes, but are afraid to address them for fear of what the public’s reaction will be. I am in my seventies and really don't care what others think. I have seen one too many kids land in prison, ruin their lives and the lives of others to stop crusading for the systems to change and give these kids the help and guidance they need to live productive “happy” lives!
  • Politicians understand right up front that many of these interventions will be costly. For too long, the “system” has tried to, “squeeze the buffalo off nickel”. It is time to fund programs that work and defund programs that have proven not to work. (I have seen numerous programs that did not work get funded over and over.)
  • By eliminating excuses, the process of building a new life begins. “We acknowledge that you have had tough breaks in your life. Some of these tough breaks were beyond your control and others you brought on yourself.” While working with youthful offenders we found that once the excuses were taken away, the youth began to grow. Others instilled many of the excuses used by the youthful offenders.
Congratulations, Massachusetts, for a magnificent start in reforming the criminal justice system within the Commonwealth! Please continue your efforts with criminal justice reform.

Mt. Sturgeon is a decorated Vietnam veteran who served with the 101st Airborne Division.

Visit the Bill Sturgeon page

Other articles by Sturgeon:



Comments:

  1. United Airlines Flights on 07/13/2019:

    We offer flight reservations at low prices. For the best booking experience, dial United Airlines flights helpline number. Our team provides the best support at United Airlines Flights Customer Service Number.

  2. DymocksBuilding on 07/10/2019:

    Fulfil your shopping needs at The Dymocks Building. Here you can find more than 120 shopping stores in one place. Sydney shopping wedding dresses sydney

  3. Delta Airlines on 07/08/2019:

    If you want to book an airfare deal, call our specialists for the Delta Airlines phone number. We are here to provide you with huge discounts and offers for air fares. Delta Airlines Phone Number is available 24/7 on your demand.

  4. pcastapremium on 06/29/2019:

    Find support for Epson Printer Drivers, Software, Manual, Setup, Installation, Wireless Connection or Wi-Fi Setup, Review, Specs, Ink, Support Windows, Mac OSX, and many more. Contact us through the Epson Printer Driver Support Number. Epson Printer Driver Support

  5. aryanoone on 06/28/2019:

    Outlook support phone number avg phone number

  6. aryanoone on 06/28/2019:

    norton product key activation norton code activation mcafee antivirus activation key

  7. kristen11 on 06/27/2019:

    HP Printer Support Brother Printer Support

  8. Southwestcustomerservice on 06/25/2019:

    If you are obstructing the flight ticket booking, you can call the Southwest Customer Service phone number. Our highly skilled team is always 24 * 7 active to provide you the best support and discounts. So dial the Southwest Customer Service Toll Free Number.

  9. Delta Airlines on 06/16/2019:

    Delta Airlines Phone Number helps the customer with all travel related questions. It provides real time information about their flight schedules and especially about airfare to their customers. To know more details visit here - https://deltaairlinesphonenumbers.wordpress.com/2019/06/07/delta-airlines-phone-number/.

  10. mywifiext on 06/13/2019:

    mywifiext Good blog! I have found here much useful information for yourself and would like to thank you for done by work.

  11. Americanphonenumber on 06/11/2019:

    Book American Airlines Reservations at the best fares from our experts. We are available at toll free 24/7, just call and book American Airlines Reservations now and get the best travel experience.

  12. alexsaim on 06/10/2019:

    QuickBooks POS Support Phone Number. Hey! we have some good news for QuickBooks Desktop Point of Sale customers. Get free QuickBooks Support and wonderful ideas by calling at QuickBooks POS Support Phone Number 1-888-833-0109. Quickbooks Pos Support phone Number

  13. lexmarkprinter88 on 06/08/2019:

    If you are planning to obtain maximum rewards, as associated with Lexmark Unit, a perfect Lexmark Printer support is necessary. There are some situations, when you may need Lexmark tech support team from qualified engineers or perhaps online support.

  14. brotherprinter88 on 06/07/2019:

    Resolve Brother Model Problems and Troubleshooting Hints by Close friend wireless model technical support and customer service workforce. Dial the 24*7 toll-free online chat Brother Customer support Helpline Contact number for instantaneous help.

  15. spiritphonenumber on 05/31/2019:

    Looking for the best offers on flight tickets? Contact our agents at Spirit Airlines Number and get best offers and deals. Spirit Airlines Number is toll-free and is available 24x7 to help the customers with their ticket booking issues.

  16. sara jacob on 05/22/2019:

    A computer printer has always been an important part of an office setup but in recent years, it has gained a huge popularity even among home users. Impressive features and Epson Printer Support Phone Number
    have made it first choice of millions of users all over the world. EPSON printers are known for high printing quality as well as impressive overall performance. But there are some problems that can arise at some point and cause discomfort to the users.

  17. sara jacob on 05/22/2019:

    HP Printer Support Phone Number
    is an amazing group of experts who are quite impressive when it comes to deliver device repair related services. The experts at this support team are quite talented and humble while rendering their help.Dial HP Printer Support number to ask for solutions against your queries, anytime.

  18. Mike Smith on 05/16/2019:

    I like this website. QuickBooks Tech Support QuickBooks Technical Support Intuit QuickBooks Support

  19. Mike Smith on 05/16/2019:

    Thanks for sharing this post. QuickBooks Support USA QuickBooks Support For Mac QuickBooks Support Number QuickBooks Support Phone Number

  20. Mike Smith on 05/16/2019:

    Thanks for sharing this post. QuickBooks Phone Support

  21. Mike Smith on 05/16/2019:

    Thanks for sharing it. QuickBooks POS Support QuickBooks Premier Support QuickBooks Pro Support

  22. Mike Smith on 05/16/2019:

    Thanks for sharing. QuickBooks Phone Number |

  23. Mike Smith on 05/16/2019:

    Thanks for sharing this post. QuickBooks Payroll Support QuickBooks Online Support

  24. Mike Smith on 05/16/2019:

    Thanks for sharing this post. QuickBooks Customer Support QuickBooks Contact Number QuickBooks Help

  25. Mike Smith on 05/16/2019:

    Thanks for sharing this post. QuickBooks Customer Service

  26. Mike Smith on 05/16/2019:

    Great Article. QuickBooks Desktop Support

  27. Mike Smith on 05/16/2019:

    Thanks for sharing this post. QuickBooks Enterprise Support

  28. Mike Smith on 05/16/2019:

    Thanks for sharing this post. QuickBooks Support

  29. johnrise on 05/13/2019:

    Nice one! This post is amazing and very important. Thanks for sharing.Awesome Post. I really like to this blog. Visit @ https://printerhelp-services.com/canon-printer-support/

  30. Airlines Phone Number on 05/09/2019:

    Dial Air France Airlines Phone Number to get best choices and comparisons for airlines tickets and related services. Our experts provide best assistance to the clients at Air France Airlines Phone Number.

  31. LanceFry on 05/06/2019:

    Good post thank you! SpyHunter Download Full morphvox pro activation code

  32. Airlines Reservations on 05/03/2019:

    Book cheap Airlines Reservations and get best discounts and deals. Our agents are always helpful to book cheap flight tickets and Airlines Reservations.

  33. Printer Support123 on 05/01/2019:

    HP is one of the best manufacturers of laptops, desktops, scanner, printers, and many other hardware devices. These days, HP is the leading name for manufacturing best printers and largest seller across the globe. Get in touch with HP Printer Support. HP Printer Customer Service is the easiest way for connecting with HP Printer Support Hp Printer Support | Hp Printer Customer Support | Brother Printer Support | Brother Printer Customer Support

  34. gerrykirsten on 04/17/2019:

    AOL Tech Support Phone Number is a customer care helpline that is offered by one of world's best mail service provider. The experts at this toll-free helpline renders all your forget password, password recovery and other related issues. Reach them anytime of day or night at AOL Tech Support whenever you need their help.

  35. gerrykirsten on 04/17/2019:

    Epson Printer Support is available whole day and night to resolve your printer problems. If you face any problem with your epson printer device like device is not working properly, cable problem, cartage problem, blank screen and others then contact at Epson Support and resolve your issue in no time.

  36. gerrykirsten on 04/17/2019:

    Dell Printer Support is a team of well experienced experts who takes care of your dell device problems. If face any problem with your device like your device is crashed, device is not working properly, paper jamming or others then contact at Dell Support and get instant help.

  37. gerrykirsten on 04/16/2019:

    Canon Printer Support is a team of experts who takes care of your canon device issue. If face any problem with your device like your device is crashed , device is not working properly or others then contact Canon Support and get instant help.

  38. gerrykirsten on 04/15/2019:

    Brother Printer Support is a team of well experienced experts available round the clock to resolve your printer problems. If you face any problem with your device like cable problem, cartage problem, paper jamming and others then reach the experts at Brother Support toll free number and get instant help.

  39. gerrykirsten on 04/15/2019:

    Acer Support is a team of well experienced experts who takes care of your Acer devices. If you are facing any problem with your Acer device like your device is crashed, device is not working properly or any other problem then contact toll free number of Acer Tech Support and get instant help.

  40. gerrykirsten on 04/15/2019:

    HP Printer Support is active helpline that is available round the clock to resolve Hp printer problems. If you face any problem with your printer like device is not working properly, paper jamming issue, cable wire problem and others then reach experts of HP Printer Support and get instant help.

  41. Geek Squad Support on 11/15/2018:

    This is one of the best article i am reading right now. great work and really informative and helpful me to. Geek Squad Support Carry on with the good work ahead. Thanks for sharing the info with us.

  42. pth16225 on 11/14/2018:

    I must say that you are my favourite author. You always bring surprised things for me everytime I see your articles. Great efforts torrent sites

  43. Ashwin121 on 10/31/2018:

    I am using this web address to learn the steps for changing My windows 10 OS computer synchronization setting windows 10 sync settings with all perfect steps and process and for this imp information you don't need to pay.


Login to let us know what you think

User Name:   

Password:       


Forgot password?





correctsource logo




Use of this web site constitutes acceptance of The Corrections Connection User Agreement
The Corrections Connection ©. Copyright 1996 - 2019 © . All Rights Reserved | 15 Mill Wharf Plaza Scituate Mass. 02066 (617) 471 4445 Fax: (617) 608 9015