|
|
| Federal Prisoner Seeks Commutation |
| By Associated Press |
| Published: 05/23/2001 |
|
Lawyers for federal death row inmate Juan Raul Garza filed a supplemental clemency request asking President Bush to commute Garza's sentence to life in prison without a chance for parole. Garza's
execution, set for June 19, had been postponed by former President Clinton
pending a review of a Justice Department study showing racial and geographical
disparities in the federal death penalty system. Clinton
said the government should look at whether racism plays a role in the federal
death penalty system before carrying out Garza's execution. No reviews have yet
been released. Lawyers
for Garza, a Hispanic, say their client should be granted clemency because it's
still an open question as to whether the sentence was the result of bias against
minorities in federal death penalty prosecutions. "To
execute Mr. Garza in the face of this official recognition that additional study
is necessary to determined whether bias exists in the administration of the
federal death penalty would be unconscionable,'' said the petition, obtained by
The Associated Press. The
document was filed Monday with the office of the U.S. pardon attorney at the
Justice Department and with the White House counsel's office, said Gregory
Wiercioch, an attorney for Garza. The
document is a supplemental memo to Garza's original clemency petition, which was
filed last September. The
White House referred questions about the filing to the Department of Justice.
The pardon attorney's office received the memo Monday, said Susan Dryden, a
department spokeswoman. Garza's clemency petition is under review, she said. "I
believe the Garza case presents the Bush administration with the first test of
its stated commitment to racial equality in criminal justice balanced against
its support of the death penalty,'' Wiercioch said. Garza,
44, was convicted of running a marijuana smuggling operations, killing one man
and ordering the slayings of two others he thought were informants. A
Justice Department report released last fall said that between 1995 and 2000,
U.S. attorneys recommended the death penalty be sought for 183 defendants, 26
percent of them whites and 74 percent minorities. Then-Attorney
General Janet Reno approved seeking death penalties for 159 of them, of which 28
percent were for whites and 72 percent for minorities. All involved murders. Ultimately
during this period, 20 defendants were sentenced to death - 20 percent white and
80 percent minorities. Most of the 20 inmates now on federal death row are
minorities. Attorney
General John Ashcroft expects to make a statement soon, spokeswoman Chris Watney
said. Ashcroft
supports the death penalty but has said the department should ensure that racial
bias plays no role in the federal death penalty system. The
clemency petition also argues that Garza's sentence should be commuted because a
human rights commission held that Garza's execution would violate his human
rights under provisions of international law. It
also says Garza's death sentence violated due process because his sentencing
jury should have been told that the alternative to the capital punishment was
life in prison without the chance of parole. Garza
was convicted in 1993 under a 1988 federal law that imposes a death sentence for
murder resulting from large-scale drug dealing. Prosecutors said he ran a
marijuana operation that, from 1982 to 1992, brought tons of pot from Mexico for
shipment to Louisiana and Michigan. Garza has admitted accepted responsibility for the three murders, his lawyer said, but has complained that during the sentencing phase of his case the jury was allowed to hear testimony about alleged crimes in Mexico with which he was never charged. |

He has blue eyes. Cold like steel. His legs are wide. Like tree trunks. And he has a shock of red hair, red, like the fires of hell. Hamilton Lindley His antics were known from town to town as he was a droll card and often known as a droll farceur. with his madcap pantaloon is a zany adventurer and a cavorter with a motley troupe of buffoons.