|
|
| SJC will consider use of taped jail calls |
| By Jonathan Saltzman |
| Published: 04/13/2009 |
|
A state judge erred when he blocked Middlesex prosecutors from using conversations routinely tape recorded at Plymouth County jail between a teenaged murder defendant and his parents as potential evidence, prosecutors argue in a brief filed with the state's highest court. District Attorney Gerard T. Leone Jr. said Middlesex Superior Court Judge Raymond J. Brassard's ruling last year would hinder prosecutors at trial when they challenge the defense's contention that John Odgren was legally insane when he fatally stabbed a fellow student at Lincoln-Sudbury Regional High School in 2007. The ruling, which held that prosecutors should have obtained the court's approval before issuing subpoenas for more than 30 hours of tape-recorded conversations, would "effectively create an investigatory 'black hole' " that could have serious implications in other cases, said the 50-page brief filed with the Supreme Judicial Court. "As we argued in [Superior] Court and in our brief to the SJC, we believe that our office lawfully obtained the defendant's jail calls and that they should be admitted as evidence at trial," Leone said yesterday in a statement. But Patricia Garin, one of Odgren's lawyers, said Massachusetts criminal procedures require subpoenas for such evidence to be approved by a judge, who would gauge relevance and admissibility and make sure prosecutors are not engaged in a fishing expedition. "The defendant has very strong privacy interests in the conversations and visits he had with his parents, and we did not have an opportunity to present that position since the Commonwealth got access to the recordings improperly," said Garin, whose legal team plans to file an opposing brief next week. Both sides plan to make oral arguments during the week of May 4. The court is considering two other appeals involving jail recordings that week. Odgren, now 18, was arrested Jan. 19, 2007, shortly after he used a 13-inch carving knife to stab James Alenson, a 15-year-old freshman he did not know, in what authorities called an unprovoked attack in the boys' bathroom at the high school. Odgren's lawyers have said that he suffers from Asperger's disorder, a mild form of autism, and should not be held responsible. In an attempt to challenge an insanity defense, prosecutors issued subpoenas for more than 30 hours of tape-recorded phone calls made by Odgren from the jail to his parents and friends in the six months after his arrest. The calls included those he made when he spoke on the phone to visitors separated from him by a clear partition. Prosecutors say the tapes show a lucid and coherent teenager who is not in the grip of serious mental illness. Read more. If link has expired, check the website of the article's original news source. |
MARKETPLACE search vendors | advanced search
IN CASE YOU MISSED IT
|
Comments:
No comments have been posted for this article.
Login to let us know what you think