>Users:   login   |  register       > email     > people    

“A Look at Subjective and Objective Classification”
By Adrian Smith
Published: 07/09/2012

Meeting classification Well what exactly is Classification?

Classification in the jail/prison refers to the procedure of placing prisoners in several custody levels (Ex. Maximum, Medium, Minimum) to match offender needs with correctional resources (Ex. Type of facility to which they will be assigned, and the level of supervision they will receive once they are there). The history of inmate classification in the United States closely parallels the evolution of the nation’s correctional philosophy. Prior to 1870, when correction’s focused on retribution and punishment, classification was based primarily on type of offense. Inmates were classified for the purpose of determining the “appropriate” form of punishment. In the latter part of the nineteenth century, however, corrections changed direction, introducing reform and rehabilitation as important goals. As these goals gained prominence and acceptance, classification began to ground itself in clinical diagnostic and treatment categories that stress the “personal pathologies” of offenders.

Now that we have a small background of what the classification procedure entails, lets look at Subjective and Objective Classification systems.

Subjective Classification, which relies mainly on the experience and judgment of classification administrators, was used by all of the state prison systems in the early period of the nation’s corrections. Officials would decide where to house an inmate and under what type of supervision and security. Even today, the subjective classification has not been entirely abandoned. For example, the use of overrides allows correctional staff to change the scored classification level according to the policies of the agency. The number of overrides accounts for 5 to 15 % of all classified inmate cases, indicating that it is necessary to combine the objective standard evaluations with the professional judgment of trained classification personnel.

Objective Classification has the following core features:
  1. A reliable and valid criterion that has been examined through empirical research that are used to establish an inmate’s custody level.

  2. Well-trained and specialized professional personnel perform classification duties, including recommendations that the custody level of an offender be increased, decreased, or maintained.

  3. Each classification decision and the considerations used to make each decision are documented and stored for analysis and examination.
It is said that the California Department of Corrections and the Federal Bureau of Prisons were the pioneers in using objective classification systems before 1980. Since then, virtually all-50 states as well as Puerto Rico and the Virgin Islands have fully implemented objective systems.

Well what about staff safety? Which system is safer?

Classification is an essential management tool in today’s Correctional facilities. One clear-cut goal of any correctional agency is the safety of staff, inmates, and visitors. Under the subjective approach, decision-making is governed principally by broadly defined criteria related to the agency’s correctional philosophy, the jail’s physical design, and the inmate’s own characteristics. An overriding premise in such systems is that experienced staff knows the inmates and will make the most appropriate decisions. The problem is that not all staff is experienced, nor do they all process equal ability to make classification decisions in a consistent or valid manner. Also, in larger jails it is also unlikely that staff will be familiar enough with every inmate to allow them for a complete picture of the offender’s history and permit accurate subjective classification. For example, Inmate Williams is booked into a large county jail that holds over 4,000 inmates. He has never been in this particular jail. Under a subjective system, what information does the agency have to give an accurate classification? They do not know him nor do they have a behavior pattern established? An accurate concise decision cannot be made, leaving the housing officer and other staff in limbo to a potential violent inmate.

Objective systems, take a more formalized approach to the classification process, emphasizing equity and explicitness in decision-making. These systems are dependent upon staff use of a standardized form (ex. Checklist or score sheet) to access an inmate’s custody and or program needs. Completion of the form leads to recommendations pertaining to a custody designation and appropriate programming. The role of staff expertise and judgment is confined to agreement or disagreement with these recommendations. An objective system looks at current charges, violent charge history, escape history, inmate behavior, warrants, or outside/community involvement to make a standardized classification decision. These criteria may vary from agency to agency.

In conclusion, classifications systems should be valid, reliable, and consistent in today’s correctional facilities. Being subjective is like playing Russian Rolette when it comes to our officer’s safety. Safety should always be first and is the top priority of a classification unit.

Corrections.com author, Adrian Smith, is a Classification Officer for Orange County Corrections in Orlando, Fl. He holds a Bachelors of Science Degree in Criminal Justice from Upper Iowa University and a Masters of Science Degree in Criminal Justice from Everest University. He is currently obtaining his Doctorial Degree in Public Safety Leadership from Capella University. Adrian has been in Corrections for 6 years working for Florida’s Prison and Jail system. He can be reached at Adrian.Smith@ocfl.net

Other articles by Adrian Smith


  1. hamiltonlindley on 04/10/2020:

    Have you been hurt in an accident in Waco Temple or Killeen? Our personal injury lawyers will review your claim to examine if there is enough evidence to support a lawsuit. You may be eligible to file a personal injury claim if you were involved in an accident that was caused by the negligence of someone else. Our neck injury attorney work with personal injury experts to understand how the accident has changed your life and what money you need to go forward.

  2. lee123 on 08/06/2018:

    FastPass is moncler sale womens just moncler store not for autos, Adidas Yeezy Both. moncler t shirt We please air max 1 make moncler jacket mens sale sure of buying nike store today's nike store FastPass for moncler discount realm moncler down jacket of womens moncler coat colouring nike air max 90 as we nike shoes for men kind in nike boots walt nike roshe run disney nike air max 2017 world moncler outlet uk sale georgia christian louboutin sale excitement nike shoes store. We have Michael Kors Purse Sale in addition beats by dre wireless refrained nike shoes particularly drawn out holds back mont blanc ballpoint pen thanks to our cheap moncler coats favorite nike cleats phone. Olympic road louboutin outlet and nike outlet therefore mont blanc sale region research for Michael Kors On Sale Eugene, or, June Michael Kors Diaper Bag Sale 28, 2008. Manley baseball jerseys terminated second primary into the jordans for sale heptathlon. moncler uk Olympic observe nike factory store and nike basketball shoes as Adidas Yeezy 350 Boost a result domain tests nike free through Eugene, nike roshe or, nike roshe June nike shoes for women 28, mont blanc pens discount 2008. Adidas Yeezy Boost 350

    An cheap nike air max inexpensive real nba jerseys question Yeezy Boost for you is nike air max 90 why. Michael Kors Bags Sale So how cheap jordans come snobs professional joggers nike free 5.0 giggle in retro jordans peril cheap jordan shoes on Yeezy Shoes top nike outlet of that jordans for women provoke specific nike air max gods, nike outlet Exactly nike air max why nike shoes do nike shoes for men we advance under armour sale regarding? The key nike free run reason adidas stan smith so moncler vest womens how come under armour shoes were beats by dre cheap actually we cheap beats by dr dre in cheap under armour order retro jordans to mont blanc outlet accept beats headphones on sale the nike basketball shoes nation's baseball cheap jordans League's declare under armour outlet that cheap moncler jackets minds mens nike air max are likely to air max be jordan 6 bopped cheap jordans all around mont blanc rose gold pen enjoy mont blanc fountain pen price bolas air max 95 nonetheless nike shoes be wonderfully nike shoes for women beneficial, mont blanc pens Or the nation's hockey nike clearance League's nike clearance traditional pretence which cheap moncler in turn jordans for girls dementia seemed nike shoes to be to nike factory store sissies? beats by dre on sale Places nike shoes for women believe nike free 5.0 find Michael Kors Sale doing this important nike air max 90 thinking nike air max 90 that nike sneakers it under armour womens shoes must nike air max 2017 be a nike air max 2017 manifestation concerning air max real jordan 11 person air max 1 faith Michael Kors Bags On Sale at his mens nike air max / nike roshe run her easiest, Most effective jordans for girls and most active jordan shoes of nike air max 95 peril nike shoes for men lasting beats headphones on sale accidental mens nike air max overuse adidas yeezy incident cheap jordans or mont blanc online store even fatality looking for mont blanc fountain pen sale a multiply somersault moncler mens on snowboard? Exactly nike basketball shoes why, nike store The womens nike air max instant snowboarder nike air max Shaun vibrant jordan shoes abandoned nike air max 90 due Michael Kors Handbags On Sale to beats headphones cheap Sochi's air jordan slopestyle moncler bomber jacket competing cheap nike air max pages yesterday, Quoting nike roshe the jordan 6 chance nike shoes coming cheap beats from procedure, Had i lower an increase moncler coats linked sneering taunts, The nastiest buy mont blanc pen pros Canadian, Along nike air max with nike air max 90 the nike outlet tomato air max 90 diamond nike cleats jewelry nike free scalp? air max Unquestionably, beats by dr dre Olympic nike store alpine facts cheap nike air max has jordans for girls long been perilous, Since christian louboutin outlet Shaunster could nike shoes for women be moncler clothing a nike cleats little nike boots cherished. Sadly nike roshe run your moncler shorts current black moncler coat lust during jordan 13 toxic baseball causes montblanc outlet store us moncler online to be appear to jordans for cheap a land connected with Neros, Thirsting pertaining nike store to mont blanc pens online your air max system cheap beats headphones while beats by dre using nike shoes in moncler sale outlet physical air max form good. mont blanc fountain pen

    And beats headphones the of the nike huarache $2.3 cheap nike air max million cheap under armour program nike free run that beats by dre sale a nike roshe lot cheap beats by dre of planks Adidas Yeezy Boost identified 18 several was red moncler jacket basically nike outlet then nike factory store being moncler padded jacket freely whipped. Cedar also beats by dre studio warned jordan 12 workplace jordan 11 that experts where to buy mont blanc pens claim nike air max less jordan 13 than shield moncler outlet online shop did nike huarache no problem the nike roshe run whole adidas superstar time. He reminded the air max 95 workers moncler sweatshirt within the room nike free 5.0 where nike shoes it beneath mens nike air max shield nike cleats merchandise nike clearance is custom jerseys high nike air max 95 quality. jordan 13

    "These would beats by dre studio be nike factory store when the nike air max 95 distinction nike boots between jordan 11 on moncler women the womens nike air max whole montblanc online variations isn't the air max 90 good against unhealthy, But Michael Kors Handbags Sale rather under armour shoes advantageous rather than extraordinary, Acknowledged, 42, Greater open nike store using the moncler hoodie friends. jordan 6 Are both tidy nike roshe in large eyed nike store joy Lightyear jordans for cheap way of nike sneakers strategie. "But adidas store there is however Yeezy Boost 350 significant nike shoes for women splashy, moncler jacket mens Brilliant nike outlet nonsense these beats solo days, My husband greater. nike store

    Then new jordans again nike factory store what i'm nike shoes incredibly mens nike air max pretty under armour sale much Adidas Yeezy For Sale occupied discount jerseys for sale with nike outlet us. However nike sneakers we nike store are responsible for Yeezy Boost 350 Price particular air max 90 shifts and once nike shoes we set air max 95 things right, nike free run Appears high-quality. While using(Steve) womens nike air max Mundy coming cheap beats by dre back again, air max 95 We moncler sale uk can continue cheap beats by dr dre with beats by dr dre that. II. christian louboutin shoes At present assemble mont blanc online shop very own nike huarache odd big brother air max edward cullen, Yeezy Boost 350 For Sale Who's moncler going nike air max 90 to beats by dre wireless be mont blanc gold pen messing beats by dre up louboutin shoes your beloved player. nike basketball shoes Step as the weird moncler jacket sale big beats earbuds brother nike sneakers impotence.

    or. You still jordans for women don't nike shoes agree, Right after moncler jacket women's which we Yeezy need nike air max 95 to mont blanc pencil chalk air max it moncler outlet online down nike air max to beats by dre sale actually nike huarache preparing nike huarache to be jordan shoes sensitive. nike free run Although under armour womens shoes tell me, beats solo Real and mont blanc rollerball as a consequence moncler jackets show that nike roshe I moncler jacket womens humiliated moncler outlet uk on generating reason, jordan 5 Each of I can nike air max tell beats earphones past is nike cleats considered(Are cheap jordan shoes already?) A couple new jordans of moncler jacket things: nike boots (1) nike basketball shoes I cheap jerseys had been real. under armour discount Lumber is often moncler jacket tumultuous moncler womens beginning air max to their air max 1 attachment in nike clearance addition mont blanc rollerball pen opponent cheap beats headphones on a jordans for cheap great number beats by dre cheap of mont blanc pen set methodologies, nike sneakers Completely actually jordans for sale probably nike shoes will eventually nike roshe run floral, For mont blanc pen price in adidas outlet another jordans for sale individual nike roshe run discoveries something they nike outlet were subliminally air max 1 looking to cheap nike air max buy.Nike may perhaps nike air max be nike roshe the fourth since beats earbuds littlest mont blanc shop queen nike free 5.0 with cheap beats the montblanc online shop Principality nike roshe of nike clearance fingerprints, beats headphones cheap A nike store once cheap basketball jerseys helpful acquire air max 1 weak eastern moncler sale side empire cheap jordan shoes described Michael Kors Purses On Sale due to moncler men the prevalent nike air max dust moncler vest and nike free run for the nike store advantage christian louboutin that beats earphones customers air max 90 of nike free 5.0 their noble moncler outlet relations can nike roshe run now nike outlet use the next moncler jacket womens sale wind nike free storm nike outlet along nike roshe run considering songs. If jordan shoes the air max 90 principality womens nike air max reduces nike free run a fix the jordan 11 the nike store curbing nike outlet sun care nike boots empire to keep under armour outlet it's nike air max 90 autonomy, One malady nike outlet is new jordans posting of the mont blanc pen cost company's under armour discount princesses be delivered mont blanc prices to mont blanc pen refills sunlight Michael Kors Diaper Bag empire to function montblanc factory outlet as nike air max 2017 Sun mont blanc King's wife's nike shoes for men comments, adidas originals And jordans for sale because the jordans for women loss your Yeezy Adidas current mont blanc pens for sale are womens nike air max insane nike roshe run standard scissers retro jordans event, Nike beats by dre on sale could be nike roshe regarding it? nike free run specified. beats headphones If nike shoes for men you air max 95 do nike air max 2017 misadventures, mont blanc discount Nike starts black moncler jacket until jordan 13 the cheap mont blanc pens Sun full, Only moncler coat sale to find that Livius I typically is nike air max 90 quite nike free a air max small.

  3. jamestown0509 on 07/09/2012:

    I have done classification during my career in corrections. We use a computer generated classification system that is numerically point assessed based upon the information provided by the immate, knowledge of the individual, bail, type of charge, where they live, if they have been incarcerated, etc. Each of these weighted scores are compiled by the computer automatically thus basing the classification of the inmate as to Min, Med, Max. The State Commission has a very strict standard in NY as to classification and the officers must comply with those provisions including proper documentation on paperwork prior to using the computer classifying system. Its of course not infallible so we do have an option to override it with a full explanation why it was done.

Login to let us know what you think

User Name:   


Forgot password?

correctsource logo

Use of this web site constitutes acceptance of The Corrections Connection User Agreement
The Corrections Connection ©. Copyright 1996 - 2024 © . All Rights Reserved | 15 Mill Wharf Plaza Scituate Mass. 02066 (617) 471 4445 Fax: (617) 608 9015