>Users:   login   |  register       > email     > people    


How to Write an Alternative Treatment Plan
By Jeffrey E. Keller MD
Published: 03/18/2019

Stethescope Many of us in supervisory positions in correctional medicine have Utilization Management (UM) duties. One common duty is to review requests from primary care practitioners for patient care procedures like a referral or, say, an MRI. We must then decide whether to approve the request or write an Alternative Treatment Plan (ATP). This process is loosely based on a similar practice done in HMOs in free world medicine, but there are important differences. In an HMO, the evaluator is deciding whether the HMO will pay for the procedure. If the requested procedure does not meet HMO criteria, the evaluator will deny the request. The procedure can still be done, but the patient and her physician will have to find an alternative method of paying for it. Also, the HMO evaluator does not offer opinions on whether the procedure is appropriate nor does she offer suggestions as to what could or should be done instead.

Correctional Medicine UM is different. Those of us doing these evaluations are not being asked about payment; we are being asked for permission to do the procedure at all. We cannot simply deny the request like an HMO can. If we do not think the procedure should be done, then we must say what should be done instead: The Alternative Treatment Plan.

When done poorly, the ATP can irritate the primary care practitioner and even create an adversarial relationship between the practitioner at the site and the UM evaluator. When done well, the ATP is a written conversation between two equal colleagues and the ATP process can actually improve patient care.

Like any other bit of writing, it is important at the outset to define who your audience is. The ATP should be written with three potential readers in mind. The first is the site practitioner who made the initial request. A bad ATP will leave the PCP feeling underappreciated, threatened and disrespected: “I don’t trust you and you are stupid.” A good ATP will leave the PCP feeling like you are on the same team and that you have their back: “You’re doing great! Let me help you.”

The second potential reader of the ATP is The Adversary, like a plaintiff’s lawyer or an advocacy group. A bad ATP will indicate that you are denying the patient reasonable and necessary medical services. A good ATP will show that nothing was denied and will not imply that any medical service is off limits.

ATPs are also read by nurses, who have to transcribe and record the ATP in the official record. A good ATP will make their life easier. A bad ATP can result in many hours of needless, morale crushing busy work.

In my experience, it does not take much more time to write a good ATP instead of a crappy one. Most UM evaluators, however, have never been taught how to write and ATP. Here is how I write mine:

Step one: Restate what is being requested.

The first sentence of the ATP should briefly summarize the case and re-state what is being requested.
  • 56 yo male s/p colonoscopy done for guaiac positive stool. Request is for a routine post procedure FU with the gastroenterologist.
  • 63 yo male with reported gross hematuria. Request is for CT of the abdomen.
Step two. Support your ATP.

The next section of the ATP contains the evidence that supports your ATP. This evidence can be pertinent positives, like x-rays, labs, previous visits. This evidence can also be pertinent negatives, like incomplete exams or missing data. Finally, this paragraph can also include pertinent research that supports your ATP, such as a quote from Uptodate, RubiconMD or InterQual.
  • The colonoscopy was negative except for a single sigmoid polyp. The pathology report on the sigmoid polyp is not attached to the report.
  • There is little clinical information accompanying the request. I do not know if the patient has other medical problems, findings on physical exam, what medications he is one or what labs have been done. Review of published treatment algorithms for the diagnostic work up of hematuria (Essential Evidence, Uptodate) show that CT is not the first diagnostic procedure that should be considered in most cases of hematuria.
Step 3. The ATP should defer the request; not deny it.

It is important to never (or rarely) use the word “denied.” Instead, you should restate what was requested and then say it is “deferred “pending whatever you want done instead, such as “Pending receipt of missing information,” “Pending complete evaluation of the patient at the site,” or “Pending case evaluation in a case review conference”
  • Routine post-procedure FU with GI is deferred, pending complete evaluation of the patient and colonoscopy findings at the site.
  • Abdominal CT is deferred pending complete evaluation of the patient at the scene.
Step four. Tell the Primary Care Practitioner what you want them to do instead.

The next sentence contains instructions to the site practitioner. This is the “ATP” and should be labelled as such. I also always date the ATP.
  • 3/11/2019 ATP: The site practitioner should obtain the pathology report on the sigmoid polyps and call me to discuss the case. The timing of follow colonoscopy will depend on the biopsy results.
  • 3/11/2019 ATP: The primary care practitioner should do a complete physical examination, appropriate labs and then discuss the case with me as to the next appropriate diagnostic procedure (ultrasound, cystography, etc).
Step five. State that whatever was requested can be reconsidered later.

I always add this last sentence as well, to reaffirm that I am not denying any medical care. “The request from the first paragraph” can be considered thereafter, if clinically appropriate or anytime if medically necessary.
  • Off-site GI visit can be considered thereafter, as clinically indicated–or at any time if appropriate.
  • CT can be considered thereafter, if clinically appropriate, or anytime if medically necessary.
Step six: Contact the PCP to let her know that her request was ATP’d.

I don’t think that PCPs should find out from a UM nurse that their request was ATP’d. They will feel much better about the process if you contact them. This also opens a method of communicating about the case if they have more questions. This can be accomplished with a simple email:
  • Hi Dr. X! Before we send this patient off-site to see the gastroenterologist, we need the biopsy report. If the adenoma is low risk, you can deliver the good news to the patient and tell him when his next colonoscopy will be scheduled. You’ll be seeing him in chronic care clinic in the meantime.
  • Hi Dr. Y! I am attaching an algorithm for work up of hematuria. As you can see, there are several things that should be done before we consider a CT. Will you please call me to discuss this case?
Putting it all together, here are the full ATPs:
  • 56 yo male s/p colonoscopy done for guaiac positive stool. Request is for a routine post procedure FU with the gastroenterologist. The colonoscopy was negative except for a single sigmoid polyp. The pathology report on the sigmoid polyp is not attached to the report. 3/11/2019 ATP: Routine post-procedure FU with GI is deferred, pending complete evaluation of the patient and colonoscopy findings at the site. The site practitioner should obtain the pathology report on the sigmoid polyps and call me to discuss the case. The timing of follow colonoscopy will depend on the biopsy results. Off-site GI visit can be considered thereafter, as clinically indicated–or at any time if appropriate. Email to PCP: Hi Dr. X! Before we send this patient off-site to see the gastroenterologist, we need the biopsy report. If the adenoma is low risk, you can deliver the good news to the patient and tell him when his next colonoscopy will be scheduled. You’ll be seeing him in chronic care clinic in the meantime.
  • 63 yo male with reported gross hematuria. Request is for CT of the abdomen. There is little clinical information accompanying the request. I do not know if the patient has other medical problems, findings on physical exam, what medications he is one or what labs have been done. Review of published treatment algorithms for the diagnostic work up of hematuria (Essential Evidence, Uptodate) show that CT is not the first diagnostic procedure that should be considered in almost all cases of hematuria. 3/11/2019 ATP: Abdominal CT is deferred pending complete evaluation of the patient at the scene. The primary care practitioner should do a complete physical examination, appropriate labs and then discuss the case with me as to the next appropriate diagnostic procedure (ultrasound, cystography, etc). CT can be considered thereafter, if clinically appropriate, or anytime if medically necessary. Email to PCP: Hi Dr. Y! I am attaching an algorithm for work up of hematuria. As you can see, there are several things that should be done before we consider a CT. Will you please call me to discuss this case?
Two more examples (minus email):
  • 53 yo s/p treatment for tongue cancer in remission. Request is for routine FU with ENT at six months from last visit. The patient has finished all of his radiation sessions. ENT note from 7/17 states that the patient is in remission and that the six-month FU visit is “prn.” The consult request notes no new symptoms. 3/11/2019 ATP: ENT consultation deferred. Per last visit with ENT, further visits are to be “prn.” The site PCP should evaluate the patient at 6 months from the last visit and again at one year from the last visit. Off-site visit with ENT can be considered thereafter, as needed–or anytime if clinically necessary.
  • 62 yo who had a liver ultrasound as part of Hepatitis C staging. The ultrasound showed a hypoechogenic polyp or cyst at the neck of the gall bladder. The radiologist says “A CT may be of value.” There is no report that the patient is symptomatic. I submitted the case to a RubiconMD radiologist, who thinks this is an incidental finding and repeat ultrasound in 6 months is a better methodology to follow this incidental finding. 3/11/2019 ATP: Abdominal CT is deferred. Per RubiconMD radiologist’s recommendation, the site PCP should order a follow up ultrasound at ~6 months. CT may be considered thereafter as clinically appropriate (or anytime if necessary).
As always, what I have written here is my opinion based on my training, experience and research. I could be wrong! If you disagree, please say why in comments.

Corrections.com author, Jeffrey E. Keller is a Board Certified Emergency Physician with 25 years of practice experience before moving full time into the practice of Correctional Medicine. He is the Medical Director of Badger Medical, which provides medical care to inmates in several jails throughout Idaho. He is also the author of the "Jail Medicine" blog

Other articles by Keller


Comments:

  1. hamiltonlindley on 03/18/2020:

    Hamilton loves his family of five and badminton. His favorite sports ball team is the McGregor Dodgeballers. He has worked as a foreman on a chain gang, and later in life he was an architect of skyscrapers and tunnels. He was forced to give up his career because he was terrible at math. Hamilton has a keen attention to detail. He enjoyed watching bowling on TV and spent most every weekend on the couch falling asleep. He was a demon at croquet. He also enjoyed war movies and baking shows. Hamilton Lindley is constantly helping others less fortunate and lending a helping hand for relatives and friends in need of encouraging words. He coaches different sports and provided guidance for people who needed it, and a few who didn’t want it.

  2. annajohnsn on 03/18/2020:

    Many people use medicines or methods that are not part of the traditional medical treatment prescribed by their healthcare provider. CBD Edibles Alternative remedies are eminently testable. It includes meditation, herbal remedies, etc. All these methods can help people to overcome the feeling that they are some patients and accept the treatment very genuinely.

  3. mubeenchonline on 02/12/2020:

    It’s very excellent information and more real facts to provided that post.Thank you for sharing this information. https://www.ace4sure.com/vendors-3.html

  4. bettybove on 11/13/2019:

    Great article. It's so necessary to know about this. I appreciate your help to readers of your blog. By the way, on https://bestwritingservice.co.uk/buy-a-motivation-letter.html you can find more useful and marvelous info on different topics.

  5. Kobymahon09 on 10/29/2019:

    If there's one thing that is worth mentioning here and now is; if anyone is seeking some serious assignment helper, there is one window that remains unsurpassed and that is the Online Assignment Expert. It is one of the windows on assignments that has the longest domain for seeking help in each and every kind of assignments that a student may fathom. Assignment maker Australia has a top-notch group of experts from established Australian Universities attached here as assignment helper. Students that hope for HD grades, despite their busy schedules that keep them for completing assignments, consider this as a one-stop-destination for completing their unfinished tasks. They support the view that the experts have a one-to-one association with experts that are available 24*7 when the assignments are assigned to them. So students, what are you waiting for, especially those that have still not looked up the service window for more that is on offer? Wait, no longer just come and seek homework that are pending only on Assignment Australia. Seriously! You won't regret.

  6. danpearson on 07/05/2019:

    The case happened in Ventura County, California. The Appellant, Nollans, filed a case against the California County Commission against his conditions to put up a bungalow on his plot along the coastline. The Nollans had leased a piece of land along the coast, but they had the option to buy if they wanted to develop it further. They owned a bungalow on their parcel of land and after years of repair and maintenance, it was rendered irreparable and they decided to demolish it and replace it with another bigger mansion. https://essayslab.com/essays/Analysis/nollan-v-california-coastal-commission.html

  7. MiaBee on 06/07/2019:

    I loved the article, keep updating interesting articles. I will be a regular reader… I am offering assignment help to students over the globe at a low price.So visit https://millionessays.com/.

  8. MiaBee on 06/07/2019:

    I loved the article, keep updating interesting articles. I will be a regular reader… I am offering assignment help to students over the globe at a low price.So visit https://millionessays.com/.

  9. Jessicawatson on 05/17/2019:

    Hi everyone. Thanks for contribution. If you lack time or strength with writing an essay, there is a website https://300writers.com/definition-essay.html where you can get help with writing an essay paper of a superb quality.

  10. Jessicawatson on 05/17/2019:

    Hi everyone. Thanks for contribution. If you lack time or strength with writing an essay, there is a website https://300writers.com/definition-essay.html where you can get help with writing an essay paper of a superb quality.

  11. hailiehills on 04/30/2019:

    business law assignment is a special kind of assignment. It requires knowledge of business thesaurus and different items. also, you need to use only facts and proved quotations. No thought and personal feeling. In addition, you can read some samples.

  12. hailiehills on 04/30/2019:

    [url=https://primeessay.org/writing-business-law-assignments.html]business law assignment[/url] is a special kind of assignment. It requires knowledge of business thesaurus and different items. also, you need to use only facts and proved quotations. No thought and personal feeling. In addition, you can read some samples.

  13. lewis on 04/24/2019:

    Dollar General is an American chain of Variety stores which was opened way back in 1939. Overall these years it has become tremendously successful with revenue now of 20.349 billion dollars. metropcs bill payment | dgcustomerfirst com | www.njmcdirect.com

  14. studymoose on 04/16/2019:

    Really master paice information we also write about health niche and this is really perfect example of good article. Studymoose papers has also good about health niche.

  15. Catarina on 04/03/2019:

    Your recommendations are very useful for beginners. I am an experienced student and have studied for a long time all the ways of writing quality papers. Now I always have a service at hand https://copycrafter.net/buy-term-papers-online.html where I order research papers and it helps me to keep my academic performance at a good level. I'm sure I'll graduate successfully.

  16. awais on 04/02/2019:

    Would you arm toning exercises with weights.arm workout womens like to get attractive weapons that look incredible as well as solid? Indeed, at that point you should attempt the accompanying https://www.apnawallet.xyz/arm-toning-exercises-with-weights/

  17. elizaseo14 on 03/28/2019:

    It doesn't matter because we do not have the 2 hours to go a gym. A home fitness gym makes sense. See how you can set up your own home fitness gym brilliant quotes about love

  18. Tiousbactine on 03/28/2019:

    Thanks for the unique content. This practice will be very useful for all medical students. The writing out prescriptions is an important part of the whole profession. As well as the general writing skill. During my studies, I turn to https://edureviewer.com/services/boomessays-com-review/ an expert review of essay services. Many people have not developed a letter and such tasks as writing an essay or thesis sounds scary.

  19. Tiousbactine on 03/28/2019:

    Thanks for the unique content. This practice will be very useful for all medical students. The writing out prescriptions is an important part of the whole profession. As well as the general writing skill. During my studies, I turn to https://edureviewer.com/services/boomessays-com-review/ an expert review of essay services. Many people have not developed a letter and such tasks as writing an essay or thesis sounds scary.

  20. Summer Watts on 03/26/2019:

    A great step-by-step guide. Thank you for posting this article! I also like the way it is written. Very interesting to read! I think it is worth starting a discussion on https://disqus.com/by/nordspil/ Everyone who is interested in - join and be free to leave a reply.


Login to let us know what you think

User Name:   

Password:       


Forgot password?





correctsource logo




Use of this web site constitutes acceptance of The Corrections Connection User Agreement
The Corrections Connection ©. Copyright 1996 - 2024 © . All Rights Reserved | 15 Mill Wharf Plaza Scituate Mass. 02066 (617) 471 4445 Fax: (617) 608 9015