>Users:   login   |  register       > email     > people    

Reducing recidivism - an exploration of one county’s effort, Part III
By Aaron M. Henderson and Deb Perry
Published: 02/16/2009

0202puzzlechain713960 Editor’s note: Last week, part two of this three-part series discussed the study’s assessment tools and the Risk/Need Principle. The series concludes this week with a look at the data and individuals of the study and the conclusions reached by the researchers.

Data Sets

The first comparative data set included those individuals who attended and successfully completed the “Thinking for a Change Program” and their activities the following three-year period. A rate of recidivism was established and compared to those who did not receive the programming.

While it is the goal to look at the entire change in programming within the Blackford County Judicial System, the common notable difference in data sets is the Thinking for a Change Program. In most cases, this program was implemented in addition to other previously required programs, (i.e. Counseling, Electronic Home Detention, GED, etc.).

For the purpose of this study recidivism is defined as:
“an individual who, within a three year period of time commits additional criminal acts similar in nature to the originating offense within Blackford County and the contiguous counties of Jay, Grant, Wells and Delaware . “
Lastly a comparative study will further analyze the client’s criminal activities as they pertain to other offenses which are not similar in nature. It is the goal of this study to provide meaningful results based on four years of change and evolution for the Blackford County Community Corrections and Blackford County Probation Departments; the cohesive working environment, and the efforts of the departments to identify and utilize programs that can and do make changes in individual’s behaviors.


Individuals referred to evidence based practice programs within the past four years have been included in this study and tracked for a period of three years to determine the effectiveness of the programming and methods of supervision. The basis of the study included individuals who successfully completed programs to individuals who did not complete similar programming.

Primary areas of concern for this study are to measure the effectiveness of programs which are matched to the offender’s criminogenic needs. This study has measured success based on offenders who do not re-offend with similar offense for which they have received treatment.

For those individuals who commit subsequent offenses different in nature to the initial offense, may not have received programs or treatment matching that particular need.

For the purpose of establishing a baseline of recidivism in Blackford County a random draw of 100 clients was pulled and evaluated on a one and three year interval. This baseline can then be compared to the current statistics of those individuals (55) who have been ordered to participate in evidence-based programming, specifically the Thinking for a Change Program.

An additional 55 clients were then selected based on similar offenses and similar risks assessment scores who were not required to participate in the programming. It was necessary to develop these three groups of individuals to further examine the impact of new policies and individualized case planning regardless of evidence based practice programs.


At the local level, comparisons have been made with current evidence based practices compared to those prior to the implementation of these practices. For the purpose of understanding the outlying impact of the programs, data has been collected and measured to include cross comparisons for offenses of any type as well as offenses committed that are similar in nature.

As noted the data has been closely matched based on offense and risk and whether or not they completed the Thinking for a Change Program, an identified Evidence Based Program.

This is independent of any additional Court sanctions and is the leading differentiating practice at this time relative to the Evidence Based Practice programming changes. The initial set of comparison data represents those clients served prior to the implementation of any Evidence Based Programming and individualized service programming.

Committed new offense regardless of type:

Prior to Implementation (100 random clients):
Within 1 year: 34.4% committed a new criminal offense.
Within 3 years: 50.5% committed a new criminal offense.
Since Implementation (55 clients):
Within 1 year w/o evidence based programs: 29.1% Committed new offense.
Within 1 year with evidence based programs: 14.5%
Within 3 years w/o EBP: 45.5%
Within 3 years with EBP: 20.0%

Committed new offense of like kind:

Prior to Implementation (100 random clients):

Within 1 year: 21.5% committed a new criminal offense.
Within 3 years: 32.25% committed a new criminal offense.
Since Implementation (55 clients):
Within 1 year w/o evidence based programs: 16.4% Committed new offense.
Within 1 year with evidence based programs: 5.45%
Within 3 years w/o EBP: 18.1%
Within 3 years with EBP: 9.1%

In short, the programs and tools implemented within the Blackford County Judicial System are working. The results noted above speak for themselves and are now a solid basis and justification for continued work in the area of Evidence Based Programming.

Ensuring that programs meet the need of the individual is critical to the continued success of the judicial system.

The potential exists to decrease expenses associated with incarceration of these individuals over a substantial period of time due to their decreased patterns of criminal behavior. These results also show that the mere changes of individualized case management for these individuals can slightly reduce the likelihood that they will reoffend, but not to the significance of implementing evidence based practices.

Efforts continue to be made in the area of additional program implementation. At the time of this writing, steps are being made to implement Prime for Life as well as other individualized case management programs to ensure that the dynamic risk factors are being addressed to further support and reduce the rates of recidivism.

Clients are now being evaluated utilizing the LSI-R assessment tool to prepare and utilize individualized case management protocol in an effort to identify the most critical areas of need for the individual. Addressing these critical needs first is now a top priority in an effort to continue the reduction of recidivism rates for Blackford County.

Works Cited

(2007). 2007 Annual Report . Indianapolis: Indiana Department of Correction.

Andrews, D., & Bonta, J. (1994). The Psychology of Criminal Conduct. Cincinnatti, OH: Anderson.

Andrews, D., Zinger, I., Hoge, R., Bonta, J., Gendreau, P., & Cullen, F. (1990). Does Correctional Treatment Work? A Clinical Relevant and Psychologically Informed Meta-Analysis. Criminology, 28(3) , 369-404.

Andrews, D., Zinger, I., Hoge, R., Bonta, J., Gendreau, P., & Cullen, F. (1990). Does Correctional Treatment Work? A clinically relevant and psychologically informed meta-analysis. Criminology, 28(3) , 369-404.

Aos, S., Miller, M., & Drake, E. (January, 2006). Evidence-Based Adult Corrections Programs: What Works and What Does Not. Washington State Institute for Public Policy , 1-19.

Dennehy, K. M. (2006, December). Offender Programming: A Smart Investment for Society. Corrections Today , 8.

Garner, A. (2008). Recidivism Rates Compared 2005-2007. Indianapolis: Indiana Department of Correction.

Menken, A. D. (1924). The Rehabilitation of the Morally Handicapped. Journal of the American Institute of Criminal Law & Criminology , 147-154.

Moll, R. (2006). Rx for recidivism. Christianty Today, 50(11) , 70-74.

Rhine, E. (2002). Why 'What Works' Matters Under the 'Broken Windows Model' of Supervision. Federal Probation, 66(2) , 38.

Stephan, J. J. (June 2004). State Prison Expenditures, 2001. Bureau od Justice Statistics , 1-9.

Aaron M. Henderson is the Chief Probation Officer for the Blackford County Courts in Hartford City, Indiana


  1. alexjoseph19 on 04/10/2020:

    King's Road playground is beautifully located right on the seafront so oodles of natural sand to get stuck into with a great selection of sturdy climbing frames, slides and other classic kids' equipment, aimed at under 8s but older are welcome as well! All the traditional components for keeping kids busy when the grown ups are sand weary and need a rest! Great visibility over the play area so no worries about keeping an eye on 'em! Car Recovery London Breakdown Recovery Edinburgh Vehicle Recovery Services Airport Taxi Peterborough Best Car Breakdown Service Local Breakdown Recovery Local Vehicle Recovery Emergency Car Recovery Local Breakdown Service Minibus Hire Carlisle Bradford To Manchester Airport Taxi Minibus Hire Hull Car Recovery Manchester Cheap Car Recovery Car Recovery Leeds Car Recovery Newcastle Van Hire Peterborough Minibus Hire Peterborough Coach Hire Carlisle Local Car Breakdown Recovery Hire Coach Peterborough Recovery Truck Leeds Airport Transfers Bradford Airport Transfers Carlisle Car Recovery Birmingham Emergency Assist Breakdown Coach Hire Hull Breakdown Recovery Manchester Coach Hire Peterborough Breakdown Recovery London Cheap Van Hire Hull Breakdown Recovery Birmingham Emergency Breakdown Service Hire Coach Hull Car Breakdown Recovery Hire Minibus Carlisle Car Breakdown Service Breakdown Recovery Glasgow Vehicle Recovery Birmingham Vehicle Collection And Delivery Vehicle Recovery Newcastle Cheapest Roadside Recovery Vehicle Recovery Leeds Breakdown Recovery Leeds Airport Taxi Hull Car Recovery Edinburgh Hire Coach Bradford Breakdown Recovery Newcastle Nationwide Car Breakdown Car Recovery Glasgow Car Recovery East London Nationwide Car Recovery Best Roadside Recovery Breakdown Recovery Services Cheap Breakdown Recovery Coach Hire Bradford Airport Transfers Hull Minibus Hire Bradford Airport Transfers Peterborough Cheap Car Recovery Leeds Van Hire Carlisle

  2. Kaitlyn on 03/28/2020:

    I have read the series share it is a good one. It does not come up to the great when compared to the first and second series but still it is a good series. Thanks for sharing this article and I liked it a lot. read this article

  3. downloadgames on 02/22/2020:

    nouvo games العاب بوبس - nouvo games العاب بوبس

  4. maxinetec on 12/01/2019:

    Vehicular ad hoc networks, cloud computing, and the Internet of Things are among the emerging technology enablers offering a wide array of new application possibilities in smart urban spaces. These applications consist of smart building automation systems, healthcare monitoring systems image processing projects using python

  5. YogTravel on 11/18/2019:

    Thanks for sharing such a informative post with in the great community you can find such information on Yoga community website too

  6. piter85 on 09/26/2019:

    Which Folks have been completely stimulating most of upon can be scarcely endorsed by Dominie's whom try and take care of planet relating to make your way those that work out ought to journey managing footwear will probably be things to place into process. VR Headset or boots available regarding generally that consideration relating to imaginative technological designs who seem to eradicate dread element because of journey runners' head exactly who normally shall be frequently haunted simply by ones severe marvelous huge Bluetooth Speaker , generally the particular substantial route people tell you without the ability to supply interest for you to contest , sweepstakes. Trek running spins around the block shall be things because of 10Km for you to 50Km via adidas superstar men shoes canada countless mountaineering together with rising affordable place. Particular by backpacking shoes or boots or boots along with managing Led Shoes Womens or boots, which will then again are usually organized when huge altitude areas, journey jogging sneakers point out related to high end in addition to suppleness. Lodging good sequence create fish a good even more pound from the foot or maybe therefore compatible SOME from the an extra shot, commonly this shape augurs as well as frequent intention shoes. For anyone who is the actual wannabe travel runner, therefore makes a difference you should Ski Goggles Womens Canada 2015 Sale Online learn ending around. The first notion exactly who wannabes is likely to often knowledge might be make your way running may perhaps be relatively much more difficult compared with high altitude planning. Will need to that was feasible, truly a common do not need to needs to be stronger and flexible concurrently. Develop this software package the excess mid sole settee that will using making you may a person's investment decision massive thumping lower hill controlling.

  7. talarkadeh.com on 08/31/2019:

    تالار پذیرایی باغ تالار تشریفات مزون آرایشگاه

    بهترین تالارهای پذیرایی تهران و و باغ تالارهای عروسی تهران را در این سایت بیابید. با آرزوی خوشبختی برای زوج های جوان یکی از مناطق جنوب تهران شهر ری است که تالارهای عروسی زیادی در آن قرار گرفته است تالارهای عروسی شهر ری تالار پذیرایی در شهر ری را می توانید انجام دهید تخفیفان تالار عروسی تالار پذیرایی تخفیفات تالار عروسی تالار تخفیف دار در تهران

  8. Hoang Ha on 05/27/2019:

    Những gì chính xác Hatha yoga thực sự là đã không thay đổi cho hàng ngàn năm, Tuy nhiên chúng tôi suy nghĩ và nhận thức của nó chắc chắn có. Ngôn ngữ là một điều mạnh mẽ, và trong nền văn hóa khác nhau cùng một từ có thể có nhiều định nghĩa, trong sự tiến hóa của thực hành yoga, cùng một từ- Hatha -đã đến để có nghĩa là những thứ khác nhau quá. Xem thêm về hatha yoga là gì tại Suckhoebabau.co nhé

Login to let us know what you think

User Name:   


Forgot password?

correctsource logo

Use of this web site constitutes acceptance of The Corrections Connection User Agreement
The Corrections Connection ©. Copyright 1996 - 2023 © . All Rights Reserved | 15 Mill Wharf Plaza Scituate Mass. 02066 (617) 471 4445 Fax: (617) 608 9015